business

U.S. Loyalty Programs Draw Investment but Fall Short on Rewards

Summarized from All Financial Services & Investing

Businesses are boosting loyalty program spending, but new research shows most consumers feel their rewards programs still underdeliver.

U.S. Loyalty Programs Draw Investment but Fall Short on Rewards

U.S. businesses are ramping up investment in customer loyalty programs even as consumer satisfaction with those programs remains strikingly low, according to new research from arrivia released Monday.

The study found that nine in ten American consumers expect to stay loyal to their preferred brand or organization, a signal of strong baseline commitment. Yet only 32% of respondents said their rewards program consistently exceeds expectations — a gap that suggests companies are leaving significant retention value on the table.

Read more Stark Future Raises €150M as Electric Dirt Bikes Outpace Gas Models →

The findings point to a structural disconnect in how loyalty programs are designed versus what consumers actually want from them. While companies may be spending more, the research implies that increased investment alone is not translating into meaningfully better experiences for members.

For brands competing in an increasingly crowded marketplace, the data underscores a pressing strategic challenge: retaining consumers who are willing to stay loyal but are not being rewarded in ways that feel compelling or differentiated. Closing that gap could determine which loyalty programs build lasting engagement and which lose members to competitors offering more tangible value.

Continue reading at All Financial Services & Investing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q.What percentage of U.S. consumers expect to remain loyal to their preferred brand?

According to arrivia's research, 90% of U.S. consumers expect to remain loyal to their preferred brand or organization.

Q.How many consumers say their rewards program consistently exceeds expectations?

Only 32% of consumers surveyed said their rewards program consistently exceeds expectations, according to the arrivia study.

Q.Who conducted the loyalty program research referenced in this report?

The research was conducted by arrivia, a loyalty and travel rewards company based in Scottsdale, Arizona, with findings released in November 2026.

More in business →